Five candidates. One decision.
A showroom-style comparison of the cars we're considering.
Score
Price 4 · Miles 5 · MPG 5 · Ins 6 · Tax 6
Total 26
Anna's notes
I hate this car with a passion. Bleh!
Kris's notes
Nice car, decent MPG. MOT is expired so the car has been sat, I'm sure they'll put one on it, but rubbers/bushes etc tend to perish faster when sat unused.
Score
Price 5 · Miles 3 · MPG 6 · Ins 5 · Tax 6
Total 25
Anna's notes
It's OK, I wouldn't be mad.
Kris's notes
I think this is too small for her. Nice car though.
Score
Price 6 · Miles 1 · MPG 5 · Ins 3 · Tax 6
Total 21
Anna's notes
This is the car that I want.
Kris's notes
Has good history and proof of significant maintenance items such as cambelt, water pump, droplinks & front brakes having been done recently. Clean MOT history. Potential to negotiate on price.
Score
Price 1 · Miles 6 · MPG 2 · Ins 1 · Tax 6
Total 16
Anna's notes
Meh.
Kris's notes
Probably a great car but it's too big for her, it'll have more dings than a doorbell in 6 months.
Score
Price 3 · Miles 2 · MPG 3 · Ins 5 · Tax 2
Total 15
Anna's notes
I'd prefer not to have an estate.
Kris's notes
Too big for her and looks as though it was previously a hire/courtesy/fleet car likely meaning it will have had a hard life on the clutch due to many new drivers having used it.
Score
Price 2 · Miles 4 · MPG 2 · Ins 3 · Tax 2
Total 13
Anna's notes
I like the BMW
Kris's notes
It's nice but scores lowest, has the shortest MOT and the last one had advisories. Shame, it could have been a winner.